It's Easter and Haley's long-distance boyfriend has got her a bunny tail butt plug. She is decked out in bunny ears and cute socks when she gets on a video chat with him. She is nervous to put the plug in her ass but is determined to please her boyfriend. It slides into her asshole without much trouble - the problem is - it won't come out. It's stuck! Haley tries various positions but isn't able to dislodge the plug from her butt! Her boyfriend wants to call emergency services but Haley refuses. She'd rather ask her stepdad Peter to help - as embarrassing as that will be, it's better than a team of paramedics. She timidly approaches Peter and rather than tell him the problem - she shows him. Peter is shocked, but he has to help his stepdaughter. He heads to the master bedroom and comes back with one of her mom's sex toys... an egg-shaped vibrator... weird! But Peter thinks it'll help loosen her up and the buttplug will slide out. It doesn't take long for his plan to work